turbines

Gas turbine or gas engine genset: what to choose for on-site power generation

In brief. Gas engine gensets are more economical up to a few megawatts and with a variable load: they have a higher electrical efficiency (over 41 %) and lower gas pressure requirements. Gas turbines are justified from tens of megawatts, where steam is needed and availability must be high. Microturbines occupy the niche from 100 kW to 2 MW, where low emissions and infrequent maintenance matter.

How to compare

The comparison rests on five features: unit output and load range, electrical and overall efficiency, fuel requirements, service life and the maintenance interval, emissions and noise. For on-site generation a sixth feature also matters — how much heat the plant needs and in what form: steam or hot water.

Output and load range

gas engine gensets deliver from hundreds of kilowatts to several megawatts per unit; a power plant is assembled from several machines and copes well with a variable load. Microturbines cover 110–1,966 kW. Gas turbines on this site are rated 5–62 MW and work best at a steady load close to the rating.

Efficiency and heat

The electrical efficiency of a gas engine genset is over 41 %, and the overall efficiency with heat recovery reaches 87 %. Gas turbines of 5–62 MW have a simple-cycle efficiency of 30.1–41.1 %, and their hot exhaust yields a great deal of steam; microturbines in simple cycle produce up to 7.7 t/h of steam, and with a recuperator fuel consumption is almost halved.

Fuel

Gas engine gensets run on natural, associated petroleum, landfill and industrial gas and on biogas at low pressure. The 2100 series of microturbines also runs on waste gases from production. Gas turbines need gas at a higher pressure and with a stable composition.

Service life and maintenance

A gas engine genset is serviced more often, and the interval to major overhaul is set by the manufacturer. Microturbines run for long periods without maintenance: the 135 series has accumulated more than 130,000 hours without remarks. Gas turbines are serviced by operating hours: inspections, medium and major overhaul.

Emissions and noise

Microturbines: NOx ≤ 25 ppm, noise ≤ 85 dB(A). Gas turbines with DLE: 25 ppm NOx. Gas engine gensets: NOx ≤ 500 mg/Nm³.

Summary table

A comparison of three types of on-site generation equipment, based on the data in the equipment sections of this website
FeatureGas engine gensetsMicroturbinesGas turbines
Unit outputhundreds of kW to several MW110–1,966 kW5–62 MW
Electrical efficiencyover 41 %—30.1–41.1 % (simple cycle)
Overall efficiencyup to 87 %——
Heathot watersteam up to 7.7 t/hexhaust 478–581 °C, steam
Fuelnatural, associated, landfill and industrial gas, biogasnatural and associated gas; waste gases (2100)natural gas
Life to major overhaulset by the manufacturerover 130,000 hours accumulated by the 135 seriesby operating hours, inspections
NOx≤ 500 mg/Nm³≤ 25 ppm25 ppm (DLE)

When to choose which

Up to a few megawatts with a variable load — gas engine gensets. From 100 kW to 2 MW with strict requirements for emissions, noise and infrequent maintenance — microturbines. From tens of megawatts, where steam is needed and availability must be high — gas turbines.

Terms used in the article

Questions and answers

Can a microturbine and a gas engine genset be combined?
Yes: on the same site gas engine gensets cover the base load with high efficiency, while microturbines supply steam for the process and run on lean gas.
What matters more when choosing — efficiency or service life?
For base load with affordable gas, efficiency; for remote sites with no service base, the maintenance interval and service life.

Sources and standards

The gas turbine and microturbine figures are taken from the sections of this website. DLE stands for Dry Low Emission.

Author

Energy Management LLC engineersAsk the engineer a question

Related

CallSend a request