Process control · solution

Anti-surge control and compressor protection

We engineer, tune and modernise anti-surge protection and capacity control systems for centrifugal and axial compressors from different manufacturers — Kobelco, Hanwha, Siemens Energy, Dresser-Rand, MHI, Howden. Surge is flow breakdown in the compressor with gas flowing backwards and shock loads on the rotor; the anti-surge system keeps the operating point at a safe distance from the surge line.

KobelcoHanwhaSiemens EnergyDresser-RandMHIHowden
A compressor train, close-up

Key facts

  • Anti-surge protection and capacity control — for centrifugal and axial compressors.
  • Three kinds of work: engineering new systems, tuning existing ones, modernising obsolete ones.
  • Equipment from different manufacturers: Kobelco, Hanwha, Siemens Energy, Dresser-Rand, MHI, Howden.
  • Implemented within the machine control system or on a separate controller on the Russian Ezan platform.
  • Tuned on site to the compressor’s actual characteristics, not only the nameplate data.
  • Modernisation goes hand in hand with compressor service: inspections, seals, bearings — one team.

What the system does

Surge line
the compressor map is converted into the coordinates of the measured parameters; a control line is set with a margin from surge
Anti-surge valve
bypass (recycle) control so that the operating point does not cross the control line during load rejections and start-ups
Capacity control
holding pressure or flow by changing speed, guide vanes or bypass — coordinated with the protection
Protection
surge detector and fast opening to bypass when the line is crossed; surge event counter
Multi-section trains
coordination of the loops of several sections and machines running in parallel
Integration
interface to the machine control system and the plant control system, alarms and event archive

Surge control line and flow margin

An anti-surge controller does not wait for signs of surge. It continuously calculates how far the operating point is from the surge line and opens the recycle valve when that distance falls below the set margin. A typical margin is about 10% of flow; depending on measurement accuracy and system speed, it is set anywhere from a few per cent to 10–15%.

On the manufacturer’s compressor map, the surge limit shifts with gas composition and with suction temperature and pressure. It is therefore converted into coordinates that are almost independent of these conditions, for example the pressure ratio and the ratio of the flow element differential pressure to the suction pressure. A single line then applies, to a good approximation, at all speeds and gas compositions.

Lines on the compressor map in an anti-surge system
LineWhat it meansWhat the system does
Surge limit linethe boundary of stable operation, from the manufacturer’s data and site testsserves as the reference; the operating point must not reach it
Surge control lineoffset from the surge line towards higher flow by the chosen margin; the margin is temporarily widened when the operating point approaches quicklythe controller opens the valve smoothly and holds the operating point on the line
Fast-opening linelies between the control line and the surge lineif the operating point crosses it, the valve opens in a step without waiting for the controller
Margin after a surge eventsurge has nevertheless been detectedthe margin is widened by a set step, and the event is logged in the counter and the archive

The margin is a trade-off: the wider it is, the earlier and more often the valve opens, and the more energy goes into compressing gas that returns to suction. A narrow margin is acceptable only with accurate measurements and a fast valve. The phenomenon itself is explained in the glossary article what compressor surge is and why it is dangerous.

Anti-surge valve and controller: speed requirements

Protection works only if the transmitters, the calculation and the valve together respond faster than the compressor reaches the surge line. During an emergency shutdown, this is a matter of seconds and fractions of a second, so the speed requirements are stricter than for ordinary control loops.

Typical requirements for the elements of an anti-surge loop
ElementRequirementWhy
Differential pressure and pressure transmittersresponse time of about 0.1 s and no more than 0.2 s; minimal signal dampingthe flow calculation keeps up with the process
Controllera fast program cycle; for surge detection systems — backup protection in case the controller fails to hold the machine — API 670 (5th edition, 2014) requires a logic solver execution time of 100 ms or less and an overall detection time of less than 500 msthe response keeps pace with the machine dynamics
Valve speedfull opening, typically within 1–2 sthe operating point has no time to cross the surge line
Fail positionthe valve opens on loss of signal or instrument airprotection is maintained if the control fails
Capacitytypically 1.8–2.2 times the highest flow on the surge linesufficient for start-up, shutdown and load rejection
Accuracysmall steps — fractions of a per cent of travel — without noticeable overshoot; hysteresis plus dead band below 1%the operating point stays close to the control line without excess recycle
Pipingminimal pipe volume between the compressor discharge, the anti-surge valve and the check valve; recycle through a coolerless gas flows back through the machine, and the suction gas does not overheat

Recommendations for such systems are collected in an informative annex to API 617 (in the 8th edition of 2014, Annex G of Part 1; the current edition is the 9th, of 2022); the standards themselves are covered in the article on API standards for compressors and turbines. The controller can be a separate unit or part of a gas turbine or compressor control system, provided its cycle time and I/O channels meet these requirements.

How we work

  1. 1

    Survey

    compressor map, scheme, instruments, existing system

  2. 2

    Engineering

    algorithms, setpoints, hardware, valves

  3. 3

    Implementation

    programming in the control system or on a separate controller, bench check

  4. 4

    Tuning on site

    surge tests, adjustment of the control line

  5. 5

    Support

    periodic check of settings, modernisation

Tuning and verification on an operating machine

The manufacturer derives the surge line from calculations and shop tests, which do not cover all operating conditions. On site, the actual line can differ from it by more than 10% because of flow, pressure and temperature measurement errors and the limited accuracy of off-design performance predictions. The surge control line is therefore finalised on the basis of surge tests.

  1. The test programme is agreed with the plant’s operating staff: operating conditions, permissible limits for vibration and rotor axial displacement, and the procedure for returning the machine to the stable zone.
  2. Tests are carried out at several operating conditions, usually three: at different speeds or guide vane positions.
  3. Flow is reduced slowly, usually by closing the recycle valve manually, until the first signs of instability appear: fluctuations of the flow element differential pressure, jumps in rotor axial position, rising vibration. The onset of surge is detected and the valve is opened at once, so that the machine returns to the stable zone within one cycle.
  4. The points are plotted on the map in the controller’s coordinates, the surge line is built from them, and the control line is set with the chosen margin.
  5. Transient conditions — start-up, normal and emergency shutdown — are checked with fast trend recording.

When the system should be checked even if no surge has occurred

  • the recycle valve is partly open at rated conditions, so the machine spends energy on gas circulating back to suction;
  • the valve oscillates with no change in operating conditions or opens in jerks;
  • the flow calculated by the controller differs from the process metering;
  • the surge event counter keeps rising, or jumps in rotor axial displacement are recorded.

After flow path repairs, the control line is checked against the new characteristic — see compressor service and repair. Anti-surge protection and capacity control are among the systems covered by the company’s rotating equipment service, together with the control, vibration monitoring and speed control systems of compressor units. After severe surge cycles, the machine’s condition is assessed from vibration and axial displacement records — a task for vibration diagnostics of turbomachinery.

For which equipment

Capacity control: methods and interaction with protection

The capacity controller holds the pressure or flow required by the process, while the anti-surge controller keeps the machine away from the surge limit. Both act on the same gas flow, so they are designed and tuned together.

Capacity control methods for a centrifugal compressor
MethodHow it worksEfficiencyWhere it is used
Speed variationshifts the entire compressor mapthe most efficient method: power falls together with capacitysteam or gas turbine drives, electric motors with variable frequency drives
Inlet guide vanespre-swirl the flow ahead of the impellermore efficient than throttling: for air compressors, about 9% better than a butterfly valve at part loadconstant-speed machines, including integrally geared compressors
Suction throttlingreduces the inlet pressurepower falls more slowly than flowsimple constant-speed schemes
Recycle or blow-offpart of the gas returns to suction, or air is vented to atmospherethe least efficient method: the energy spent compressing the bypassed gas is lostsurge protection and operation below minimum flow

When the anti-surge valve opens, the discharge pressure drops and the capacity controller starts to restore it. Without decoupling, the two loops interfere with each other and can destabilise operation up to a trip, so feedforward links between them are built into the algorithm.

For machines running in parallel, the load is shared so that each machine operates at the same relative distance from its own control line. No machine then goes into recycle while another carries the load.

Questions and answers

What is surge and why is it dangerous?

Flow breakdown when the flow drops below the critical value: gas moves backwards through the compressor, causing pressure pulsations and shock loads on blades, bearings and seals. More in the glossary.

Can you modernise a system on another manufacturer’s compressor?

Yes: we work with Kobelco, Hanwha, Siemens Energy, Dresser-Rand, MHI, Howden and other machines — based on the characteristics of the specific compressor.

Does the whole control system have to be replaced?

No: the anti-surge loop can be implemented on a separate controller integrated with the existing system or within a new machine control system.

How is the tuning verified?

On site — by controlled tests approaching the <a class="term-link" href="../glossary/compressor-surge/index.html" title="What is compressor surge">surge line</a> and checking the bypass response; the results are recorded in a test report.

What data is needed to assess an existing anti-surge system?

The manufacturer’s compressor map with the surge line, the piping and instrumentation diagram with valves and coolers, data on the flow element and transmitters, the anti-surge valve datasheet with its stroke time, the algorithm description and the current setpoints. Trends of flow, pressures and valve position during start-ups and shutdowns, together with the surge event log, are very helpful: they show where the settings differ from the machine’s actual behaviour.

Can the protection be set up without surge tests?

Temporarily, yes: from the manufacturer’s map, but with a wider margin and therefore more recycle. The manufacturer’s surge line does not account for site measurement errors or for wear and fouling of the flow path, and it can differ from the actual line by more than 10%. The line is therefore confirmed by tests at the first opportunity — during commissioning, after a repair or in a window agreed with the operating staff.

Expert in charge

Process control systems

Manufacturers’ names and designations are used to identify the equipment we supply and service. Trademarks belong to their respective owners. Energy Management LLC is an independent engineering company.

CallSend a request
Service requestRequest a quotationData sheet